Skeleton Creek by Patrick Carman: Review

In Skeleton Creek by Patrick Carman, Ryan has just returned home after spending two weeks in the hospital due to an accident. Alone in his room, he documents the events leading up to his tumble in his journal. He and his film making best friend Sarah, attempted to find out the truth about Skeleton Creek. What are the townspeople hiding? What is the mystery behind the great dredge in the woods? Even after his accident and warnings from his parents, Ryan and Sarah continue to pursue the truth, putting themselves into even more danger.

I don't usually review YA but when I was approached about reading this novel, I felt that I couldn't say no. It's something I've never seen anywhere else. You see, Skeleton Creek isn't just a novel. It's a multi-media experience. After reading a section of Ryan's journal, he prompts the reader to go to Sarah's website where she has uploaded a video for Ryan to view. At first, I thought this would annoy me but it was a lot of fun. It was quite an interesting (and I'll bet expensive) concept. Both the author and publisher have taken quite a risk, but it works.

The book: I'd like to review the book and the video separately, so I'll start with the book. It's written as a journal, in fact it looks like a journal, hand written with emails taped in and all. At first, I was a little thrown at how mature Ryan's writing is, but it turns out that Ryan is considered 'gifted'. That made it more believable. The story hooked me right away. Why is Ryan so scared? As the novel progresses, Ryan starts to piece together the real story of Skeleton Creek and I couldn't put it down. There are a few minors issues but it didn't bother me.

The videos: Patrick Carman included the online videos as a way to catch the interest of that elusive group, boys. And really what boy doesn't love online videos? I also doesn't hurt that the girl cast as Sarah is adorable. I give Carman 2 thumbs up for creating a smart (though reckless) girl as Ryan best friend. The videos are well made and though somewhat Blair Witch-esque, you needn't worry about vertigo. The shaky camera work is limited.

Overall, it was an enjoyable read/watch. If I had read this in my youth, I would have loved it! It was just my thing at that age. It was downright creepy and I'm glad I read it in the afternoon not night. I'm not sure how I feel about the end. I was left with more questions and I hope there will be a sequel.

Skeleton Creek is an interesting experiment. How do I feel about the format? It's an entertaining novelty but I do have some qualms. The book requires the reader to have internet access. While most people have that, there are some who do not. It's not exactly portable (not for me, anyway), I needed to be handy a computer while reading it. I couldn't just throw it in my purse and go. Luckily, it's a quick read. I finished it in under 2 hours. Also, will someone 10 years from now pick it up from the library and be able to access the videos on the website. Will it still be there? We shall see.

For ages 10+
Available Feb 10, 2009


Patrick Carman talks about the book here:

Other Reviews:


  1. I'm so glad you liked it! I loved it as well. I can't wait for the sequel to come out!

  2. Fascinating take with the different media. Wow.

  3. Very interesting! It's nice to see innovation in a world where it's hard to imagine anything new!

  4. I was intrigued by the combination of book and video, but I declined to review this one because it just isn't practical for someone who reads primarily on the train. Sounds like a good one, though.

    Diary of an Eccentric

  5. This looks as sounds awesome! I have not seen multimedia type books like this! A very cool idea! I am going to go and see if I can find it online now, lol.

  6. I've heard good things about this one. The idea sounds pretty cool. My library doesn't have it, :( but I'm sure they will get it eventually.

  7. I'm reading Skeleton Creek next - my plan had been to get my daughter to read the book with me (she's not a reader, but a filmmaker) but it's been difficult to find the time to do it with her (so many high school activities!). I might get her to just watch the videos with me when I'm at the video parts of the book!

  8. I need to read/watch this!what a cool idea.

  9. I enjoyed the book as well. You can find my review here:


    There's mine!!


Thanks for visiting! Please leave a comment. I've disabled Anonymous comments since I've had a barrage of Anon spam lately. Sorry about that.
Also, if you leave a legit comment but it contains a spammy link, it will not be published.