July 30, 2012

Tipping the Velvet by Sarah Waters: Review

Pin It

tippingIt took me so long to read Tipping the Velvet, not because it wasn’t good, but because I was so annoyed with the protagonist Nancy that I had to keep walking away from it. Blargh!

Nancy Astley is just an ordinary fish monger’s daughter, until she discovers the theatre and more specifically Kitty Butler. Kitty’s act is singing as a male impersonator. Nancy falls head over heels in love and when Kitty must leave for another gig, Nancy signs on as her dresser. It doesn’t take long for the two to become lovers and then to Nancy’s surprise a duet upon the stage. Nancy trades her skirts for men’s trousers and a new name: Nan King. Nan King is a star in her own right with plenty of her own admirers but she only has eyes for Kitty. Everything is peachy until it isn’t and Kitty breaks her heart.

I’m going to get Spoilery…

Nan! Grr. First, she acts appropriately after Kitty’s revelation: moping and crying and acting like an angsty teen, all that she’s missing is blasting “All By Myself” for hours at a time. It’s what she does after she puts her pants on that’s the problem. She stumbles into prostitution, as a dude. It’s almost impressive how she manages this. Her reasons for taking on this career drove me insane: Revenge. Revenge? She gives some explanation but all I could think of was Alexandre Dumas and what he might say to this.

alexandre dumas

I don't know how she figures she's getting back at anyone. Kitty can’t see her. What does she get out of it? Some weird kick when men tell her she’s “such a pretty boy” while she laughs to herself? As for money, she could have gone to her theatre friends for help if she needed it but her pride wouldn’t let her. Worse is to come because a nasty rich lady takes her in and says “I own your soul!” Nancy, being Nancy, says *shrug* “okay.” She turns her back on the only true friends she has because the evil lady has lots of money and she’s hot for teacher. And so begins the most heartless relationship ever created. 

End of Spoilers.

Later, when she finally gets herself together, someone lays out for her all her deeds and the flawed logic that lead to them. It takes that for her to see just how much of a brat she has been. She lets things happen to her and then blames destiny for it, like she has no responsibility for her own actions. It was this attitude that made me frustrated with Nancy and found it hard to sympathize with her. 

Thankfully, Nancy does grow as a person and by the end becomes less self-absorbed. It takes awhile.

I didn’t enjoy this Sarah Waters as much as the other two I read: Affinity and The Little Stranger. They, being more creepy, were different in tone. I think I had come to expect books with that feel. Very Wilkie Collins-ish. I would have loved it more had I read it before the others. Tipping the Velvet is Waters’s debut novel and I thought parts dragged on too long. That’s not to say it wasn’t brilliant in places. It was shocking and funny and heartbreaking. I’m always impressed by Waters’s ability to convey emotion. The reader is with Nancy watching Kitty’s act over and over, falling in love with Kitty the actress like a modern teen might fall in love with a TV star. I might not have always liked Nancy but she always felt real.

What can I leave you with? It’s bold. Waters doesn’t pull any punches. Be prepared. There are many Sexytimes. I’ll never look at the Victorians the same way again.

Ratings:

Photobucket

Photobucket

13 comments :

  1. I skipped the spoilery bit because I'm planning to read this next - I've read all Waters' other books, and other than Night Watch, which I thought a bit rambly and plotless, I loved them - impressed with her writing and storytelling. But an unsympathetic character can put you off an otherwise good book. I'll have to see if I get on any better with Nancy and Kitty.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have Fingersmith on the TBR pile, which I must read sometime too.

      Delete
  2. When a protagonist is that annoying, it means the book is well written for sure!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I saw the miniseries back in the day and it sounds like it was pretty true to the book. Nan was SUPER annoying, and I never got her obsession with Kitty anyway.

    I think I need that Dumas image.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Because she was her first wuuuuuuve! And no one in the history of the world had ever been in love or heart broken before. Ever.

      You make take Monsieur Dumas.

      Delete
  4. Hmm, I watched the mini-series too and just found Nan to be behaving in the manner of an adolescent without a good support structure, but I know the miniseries is so NOT the book!

    I could see how it being in the first person could make it more annoying. Now I'm curious to see for myself!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I guess she could have been seen that way but she got on my nerves. Give it a try!

      Delete
  5. I have Tipping the Velvet on my stacks. I also like that gothic feeling in Affinity and The Little Stranger, so I've been a little hesitant to pick this one up. Will get to it one day soonish.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah, I was curious about this one but knew it would be different. I loved the other 2 books.

      Delete
  6. I've not read this one by Waters, but I've liked the other two books I've read by her! Maybe instead of this one, I'll do The Little Stranger or Night Watch.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I stopped reading when you got spoilery but just wanted to say that at some point, I do plan on reading this one. I've got so many books to read at the moment that I am set until at least April of next year!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hey thanks for reviewing this! I'll be sure to start with Sarah Water's other books before this one.

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for visiting! Please leave a comment. I've disabled Anonymous comments since I've had a barrage of Anon spam lately. Sorry about that.
Also, if you leave a legit comment but it contains a spammy link, it will not be published.

nrelate