August 17, 2007

The Mists of Avalon: Review

Pin It


The Mists of Avalon is the Arthurian legend told from the point of view of the women. The men are there, of course, but we only get to see into the minds of the most important ladies of the legend. Mostly, we see the world of Avalon and Camelot through Morgaine, sister of Arthur and priestess of Avalon. She often speaks directly to the reader, unlike the others. Morgaine goes through many changes throughout the story.


When the story begins, Morgaine is only a toddler. Women and the Isle of Avalon still hold power over Britian but it's time is waning. Christianity is becoming a powerful lure to the inhabitants, particularly the men. Morgaine's mother, Ingraine, is the unhappy Queen of Cornwall, given in marriage by her sister, the Lady of Avalon, Viviane, to the old man Gorlois. Viviane informs her that she will have a child by Uther Pendragon, the future king she hopes will defend the old religion. She is resentful of Viviane's meddling but still finds herself falling passionately in love with Uther.


After marrying Uther, Ingraine renounces the old religion in favour of Christianity, to spite Viviane. Viviane asks Ingraine to let Morgaine come with her to Avalon, there to become priestess and her successor. Morgaine is happy there until she feels herself used by Viviane in the name of the Goddess. Morgaine leaves but never renounces the old religion. She finds herself defending the old ways as the new king, her brother Arthur, forgets his promises to Avalon.


In Bradley's novel, the picture she paints of Arthur is a man too diplomatic to be king. He wants to make everyone happy, including his wife Gwenhwyfar, who is a fanatical Christian. Their arguments were one part of the book I found tedious and annoying. It was always the same old arguments. I suppose Bradley was trying to show how Gwenhwyfar gradually chipped away at Arthur's resolve to defend Avalon, but I found it tiresome. Gwenhwyfar was not easy to sympathize with, even with all her heartbreak. She's bitter and angry.


The religious struggle between the old ways and Christianity is a major theme in Mists. It seems to me it came down to a power struggle and not really about the spiritual well-being of Britons. The old religion wanted women to hold the power, and Christianity wanted them not only to have none, but be ashamed of being women. (I've always had a problem with that.) Morgaine at some point comes to this realization:

"I came to see that my quarrel was never with the Christ, but with his foolish and narrow priests who mistook their narrowness for his."

But as time goes on, more and more of the old pagan ways become absorbed by the new religion. I think the Epilogue was a nice touch and Morgaine was finally satisfied.

There were parts I thought too long and ones I didn't think long enough but it was a great read and a different way of looking at the old story.
This was a TBR Challenge read.
4/5

10 comments :

  1. 4 is okay. I know what you mean about the arguments between Arthur and his wife. Most Arthurian literature blames her for the fall of Camelot entirely, and that takes away from her coming across as having any redeeming qualities. Some newer fiction has her in a positive light and people seem to like that better. But in the beginning, it was her fault, so this is a more realistic portrayal of her.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh, are you going to read the rest of the series out of curiousity?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Very nice review!! I'm really looking forward to reading this one. I should dig it off my shelf!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Kailana- I didn't know there was more! I'll have to check them out, though I don't know when I'll get to them.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Ask and ye shall receive:

    The Series:

    Ancestors of Avalon
    Ravens of Avalon
    The Forest House
    Lady of Avalon
    Priestess of Avalon

    And, then, actually, chronological Mists of Avalon is the last book in the series. I cringe to think of starting with Ancestors of Avalon, though. Please don't judge the rest of the series by that book if you do read it. I haven't read Ravens yet, I just got it yesterday, but the other three are good! They talk about different aspects of history.

    Yeah, I know you didn't ask, but, well, I like to talk. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. When I finished this book I was glad I had read it and felt like I learned much more about Arthurian legend, but it was not a book I would have recommended to anyone. I'm not sure why I had that feeling. I like that quote you shared.

    ReplyDelete
  7. You know, I keep on reading mostly good things about this book, but I still never bother to pick it up at the book store. What's stopping me? Maybe I'm waiting for the right moment.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Stephanie- I think you would like it.

    K- Thanks for the info.

    Booklogged- I think it falls into a funny category: part history, part fantasy.

    Imani- It's a huge book and there are a few slow parts but I really enjoyed it.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I love the American cover, it's much nicer than the UK one. I love this book so I might have to double up with an American copy. I think the quote you put at the end from Morgaine sums up my attitude as well, it's not Christ or even most Christians who wind me up, it's the way certain fundamentalists portray their version. I'm glad you enjoyed it for the most part. There is an American dvd version that is quite good you might like to check out too.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I am a big fan of books about the Arthurian legend, and I like really like this book because it expands upon the stories of the women of the legends, especially Morgaine. But, I agree with the weaknesses you picked out as well. Great review!

    ReplyDelete

Thanks for visiting! Please leave a comment. I've disabled Anonymous comments since I've had a barrage of Anon spam lately. Sorry about that.
Also, if you leave a legit comment but it contains a spammy link, it will not be published.

nrelate